Welcome to The Spoiling Dead Fans

Wanting to join the rest of the survivors? Register your free account today!

Register
  1. Welcome to The Spoiling Dead Fans! We encourage you to register and post and become a part of the family. After registering (which is painless I swear), you may want to start by posting in the Introduction thread entitled 'My Name Is' which is located here: http://www.thespoilingdeadfans.com/forums/my-name-is.3/. We have so many features here besides spoilers: discussion of characters, ships, speculations, comics, TWD video games and more. Don't be shy! ~ShinyFirefly, Owner & Admin

Rick Screaming In The Boxcar Theory.

Discussion in 'Predictions' started by Rapindeas, Mar 24, 2014.

  1. Morgan Jones
    Rapindeas

    Rapindeas Walker

    6
    24
    VIDEO GAME SPOLIERS AHEAD

    Hey, i'm Rapindeas.

    As you all know should know if you don't there is a scene in the Season 4 Finale "A" where Rick opens the door to a Train Carriage/Boxcar what ever you want to call it. I've been wondering what it could be. I have come up with this theory. (Video Game Spoilers Ahead)

    In the The Walking Dead video game by Telltale they go to dairy farm which is run by a group of cannibals.
    There is a guy named Mark who had injured himself and wasn't able to move. The were about to eat dinner and Lee asked if could be excused. He went looking for Mark and when he found Mark he was was locked in a room with both his legs cut off, they were eating Mark for dinner!

    My thoughts are that Rick opens that Boxcar to find someone maybe Beth* dead with there legs or arms gone! And the group is eating them! What do you guys think? Who do you think might die? :)

    Mark_Maimed.png
  2. Rick Grimes 5
    Hackman

    Hackman Site Rick - Site Ringleader Staff Member Site Host

    8,426
    28,971
    I think you have a very good theory.

    Until I can come with a better one than you--and so far I can't--I'll stick with yours!
  3. Sasha 3
    Nat Allya

    Nat Allya Content Queen I NatIceyium /Madame Blanc Staff Member Content Manager

    6,252
    26,330
  4. Daryl Dixon 3
    Imogen13

    Imogen13 Board Moderator l Teacher of the Dead Staff Member Board Moderator

    691
    3,355
    I think it's entirely possible, yes. It's certainly one theory - Terminus being a combination of the comic Hunters with the video game St. John's Dairy, but with a more sinister leader in Gareth. Mary reminds me of the lady in the video game (I haven't played the game but based on what I've heard about the St. John's incident).

    The other going theory is the boxcar is separate from the Terminus battle and is the focus point of the showdown with the Merry Band. Something goes down in that boxcar, possibly concerning an attack on Carl (via the comic book) and Rick goes ape and literally tears them apart. The scream could be when he sees them attacking Carl or while he's attacking them.
  5. Rosita
    daniel414141

    daniel414141 Tracker

    1,540
    7,398
    It does make sense, but why would they eat beth inside the boxcar? the cannibals own this place and the old lady was cooking at the garden or whatever it was
    roman cavalry and Hackman like this.
  6. Rosita
    daniel414141

    daniel414141 Tracker

    1,540
    7,398
    Now this makes more sense to me
    roman cavalry and Hackman like this.
  7. Morgan Jones
    Rapindeas

    Rapindeas Walker

    6
    24
    Yeah, that is a really good theroy! Imagine if Rick lost Carl imagine the state he would be in for all he knows Judith is dead. I guess it will all be relaved Sunday night! So pumped :D
    roman cavalry and Hackman like this.
  8. Daryl Dixon 3
    Imogen13

    Imogen13 Board Moderator l Teacher of the Dead Staff Member Board Moderator

    691
    3,355
    [​IMG] Here's who "Mary" reminds me of - Brenda St. John from the video game. She also "offers them dinner" when the protagonists enter the farm.

    [​IMG] The group entering the farm....Look familiar?
    roman cavalry, NavyDad and Hackman like this.
  9. Rick Grimes 5
    Hackman

    Hackman Site Rick - Site Ringleader Staff Member Site Host

    8,426
    28,971
    what did she say--and where? :woot:
    roman cavalry and marthalawson21 like this.
  10. Rick Grimes 5
    Hackman

    Hackman Site Rick - Site Ringleader Staff Member Site Host

    8,426
    28,971
    ***Hackman faints***
    roman cavalry and NavyDad like this.
  11. Daryl Dixon 3
    Imogen13

    Imogen13 Board Moderator l Teacher of the Dead Staff Member Board Moderator

    691
    3,355
    Wake up, Hackman!

    [​IMG]
    roman cavalry and Hackman like this.
  12. DarkKnight

    DarkKnight Termite

    201
    517
    Tyreese? We haven't seen him and carol since grove. Maybe they made it to terminus ahead of the rest of them. I like him for it because of his infected arm, "you're eating tainted meat".
    roman cavalry likes this.
  13. jennaj

    jennaj Termite

    121
    480
    Trying to lighten the mood here for y'all. What could be in the boxcar that sets Rick off?
    Hair clippers/beard trimmer?
    Stevie, DarkKnight, Evelina and 3 others like this.
  14. Maggie Greene 5
    roman cavalry

    roman cavalry Board Moderator - maggie centurion Staff Member Board Moderator

    4,224
    15,502
    lol
  15. Sasha 3
    Nat Allya

    Nat Allya Content Queen I NatIceyium /Madame Blanc Staff Member Content Manager

    6,252
    26,330
    Can't remember where. I will try to find it later. I don'tlike to talk for the others but she basically says that no one dies and that Rick screams because when he opens the boxcar he finds the stock of human meat after having eating some himself. Dun! Dun! Dun!
  16. Rick Grimes 5
    Hackman

    Hackman Site Rick - Site Ringleader Staff Member Site Host

    8,426
    28,971
    All I know is this is going to be a LOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOONG week

    I don't think I'll make it to Sunday night

    AGONY ! A---GO---NY! :rickcry:
    Last edited: Mar 25, 2014
  17. Maggie Greene 5
    roman cavalry

    roman cavalry Board Moderator - maggie centurion Staff Member Board Moderator

    4,224
    15,502
    yes it will be a long week of wondering what going to happen:unsure:
    Nat Allya and Hackman like this.
  18. Rick Grimes 5
    Hackman

    Hackman Site Rick - Site Ringleader Staff Member Site Host

    8,426
    28,971
    I know--you are worried about Maggie--aren't you @roman cavalry ?
    Nat Allya and roman cavalry like this.
  19. Maggie Greene 5
    roman cavalry

    roman cavalry Board Moderator - maggie centurion Staff Member Board Moderator

    4,224
    15,502
    yes very worried
  20. Sasha 3
    Nat Allya

    Nat Allya Content Queen I NatIceyium /Madame Blanc Staff Member Content Manager

    6,252
    26,330
    She is not going to die because I say it. Period.. I'm the boss.
    roman cavalry and Hackman like this.

Share This Page